HRF Monthly

Extension of policing powers to BSF: comparable international experiences BYRAVI NAIR OCTOBER 25, 2021

/ / HRF Monthly
 OCTOBER 25, 2021

Northern Ireland’s Royal Ulster Constabulary experience offers a lesson to Indian lawmakers: the militarised policing of a local population by a centrally-controlled force that has been awarded extraordinary powers without accountability measures will likely result in human rights violation, explains RAVI NAIR.

————

MOST modern democracies adhere to the policy of separation between the military and the police. Many nations have made limited exceptions for certain paramilitary forces.

Nevertheless, as Northern Ireland’s experience illustrates, the mixing of forces with inherently different mandates (armed combat versus law enforcement) and targets (enemy versus local citizen) is likely to do more harm than good.

…

Extension of policing powers to BSF: comparable international experiences BYRAVI NAIR OCTOBER 25, 2021Read More »

HRF Monthly

Shifting the borders inland: Policing powers of the Border Security Force

/ / HRF Monthly
OCTOBER 21, 2021
 
Amidst the recent decision to increase the jurisdiction of the Border Security Force in West Bengal, Punjab and Assam, RAVI NAIR examines the encroachment of Constitutional federalism by a union government gradually inching the country towards an authoritarian state.
 

Union government’s decision to extend the jurisdiction of the Border Security Force (BSF) to over 50 km in three states – namely, West Bengal, Punjab and Assam, from the barbed wire fence with Bangladesh and Pakistan, along with the grant of policing powers, is one more building block in the creation of a unitary authoritarian state.

…

Shifting the borders inland: Policing powers of the Border Security ForceRead More »

HRF Monthly

The right of private defense – a legal view

/ / HRF Monthly

An SAHRDC backgrounder

 
SEPTEMBER 28, 2021
 
RAVI NAIR of the SOUTH ASIA HUMAN RIGHTS DOCUMENTATION CENTRE provides an analysis of the right to self defense relating to person and property under the prevalent criminal jurisprudence, and how the Supreme Court has looked at it over the course of time.
 

It is the duty of the State to protect its citizens and their property from danger. However, there are circumstances wherein the State machinery is not available or is passive.

…

The right of private defense – a legal viewRead More »

HRF Monthly

Indian Diplomacy in Afghanistan – Hoist on its own petard

/ / HRF Monthly

1 September 2021

Think piece 3 on Afghanistan – Can be freely used with due credit to SAHRDC

The Indian Express of 30 August 2021 mentions that 260 Indians are still stranded in Kabul. Representatives of Indian NGOs from the health, education and medical sectors have informed SAHRDC that over a 100 of them are NGO workers. Most of them have little money to buy even the bare necessities. Banks in Kabul opened a few days ago. Each account holder is allowed to withdraw small amounts. Most of the Indian NGO staff is resigned to losing their savings from their employment in Afghanistan.

…

Indian Diplomacy in Afghanistan – Hoist on its own petardRead More »

HRF Monthly

Afghanistan- A tragedy foretold – The setting of the Card table with cardsharps all around

/ / HRF Monthly

  25 August 2021

 SAHRDC Think Piece 2 on Afghanistan (May be freely reproduced with due credit to SAHRDC)

The mythological yarns of Hinduism are many splendoured.  They make for many hours of wonderful reading. They also attest to the fertility of the Hindu imagination more than any sound historical record.  The revanchist Hindutva supporter who dreams of an ‘Akhand Bharat’, or ‘Greater India’, would like us to believe that the Gandhara kingdom mentioned in the great Indian epics of the Mahabharata and Ramayana comprises most of what was part of Pakistan’s North West Frontier province, now called Khyber Pakhtunwa, along with modern day Eastern Afghanistan.

…

Afghanistan- A tragedy foretold – The setting of the Card table with cardsharps all aroundRead More »

HRF Monthly

No milk of human kindness for Afghans or refugees – The Hindutva government’s stone hearted self-defeating Afghan policy

/ / HRF Monthly

 SAHRDC Think Piece 1 on Afghanistan: May be freely reproduced with due credit to SAHRDC

 20 August 2021

The cussedness of a Hindutva-based policy taking precedence over humanitarian or even geopolitical considerations, implicit in the statement of the Ministry of External Affairs on 16 August 2021, takes one’s breath away.

“We have been issuing periodic advisories for the safety and security of Indian nationals in that country, including calling for their immediate return to India… We had circulated emergency contact numbers and had also been extending assistance to community members,” the MEA spokesperson said.

…

No milk of human kindness for Afghans or refugees – The Hindutva government’s stone hearted self-defeating Afghan policyRead More »

Scroll to Top